Bordeaux 2009: the biggest score differences, who is right?

Professional tasters don't always agree!
For those among you who had the chance to taste 'en primeur',  compare their findings to your tastingnotes and let us know who is right.

Those of you who are less privileged will have to rely on the expert they have the most affinity with when buying Bordeaux wines en primeur.

Wine name Avg Max Min Dif Parker WSP Tanzer Quarin
  Clinet (Chateau) / Pomerol 93 99 86 13 97 - 100 95 - 98 89 - 92 86
  Gracia (Chateau) / Saint Emilion 91 97 85 12 96 - 98 92 - 95 88 - 91 85
  Bellevue-Mondotte (Chateau) / Saint Emilion 93 98 88 10 95 - 100 95 - 98 88 - 91 88
  Pavie-Decesse (Chateau) / Saint Emilion 93 97 87 10 93 - 96 95 - 98 93 - 96 87
  Fleur de Gay (Chateau La) / Pomerol 91 95 86 9 93 - 96 90 - 93   86
  Figeac (Chateau) / Saint Emilion 93 99 90 9   97 - 100 88 - 91 92
  Hosanna (Chateau) / Pomerol 95 99 91 8 98 - 100 93 - 96 92 - 95 91
  Pavie-Macquin (Chateau) / Saint Emilion 94 98 90 8 94 - 96 96 - 99 91 - 94 90
  Peby-Faugeres / Saint Emilion 94 98 90 8 93 - 96 96 - 99   90
  Oratoire (Clos de l') / Saint Emilion 91 94 86 8 91 - 93 92 - 95   86

Bookmark and Share DotnetKicks dotnetshoutout
Tags: ,
Categories: vintage report

Permalink E-mail | Kick it! | DZone it! | del.icio.us Comments (0) Post RSSRSS comment feed